The Learning Zone
Practical design, formatting, and editorial guidance for authors and publishers bringing a book to print.
Questions to Ask Before Paying for Comprehensive Editing or Rewriting
Comprehensive editing and rewriting cost the most and are the hardest to judge. Here are four questions to ask an editor before you pay.
Red Flags That Signal an Editing Service Is Cutting Corners
A fast, cheap edit can look like a deal until the typos show up. Here are the red flags that an editing service has cut corners, and one nuance.
What to Look for in an Editor Before You Hire One
Editors aren’t licensed, so price and a sample edit only go so far. Here’s what to look for in an editor, starting with their style guide.
Best Practices for Giving an Editor Feedback Without Starting Over
Specific, well-timed feedback keeps a round of edits moving forward. Here’s what that looks like on a real project, and what to bring to your next round.
Best Way to Track Manuscript Versions Between Editing and Design
Manuscript versions get lost fast between an editor and a designer. Here’s the three-part file system I built after designing a book from the wrong version.
Best Order of Operations for Editing, Formatting, and a Final Proofread
The order that holds up is editing first, formatting second, a final proofread last. Here’s why, and what happened when a manuscript only looked ready for layout.
Is Paying for Both Editing and Formatting Worth It, or Can You Skip One?
Skipping editing or formatting looks like an easy budget cut. Here’s what each one protects, and what buying both together looked like on a real project.
What Does Rewriting Cost, and When Is It Actually Worth Paying For?
Rewriting is the most expensive editing tier. Here’s what the rate actually buys at real manuscript lengths, and how to tell whether your manuscript genuinely needs it.
Why Does Comprehensive Editing Cost So Much More Than Copy Editing?
Comprehensive editing costs more than copy editing because each page takes longer. Here’s what the higher rate actually pays for, using a real manuscript as the example.
What Does Proofreading Actually Cost, and What Does the Price Depend On?
A per-250-word proofreading rate doesn’t mean much until it’s tested against a real manuscript — here’s what actually happened when one project’s price got recalculated.

